Pumpkin Chocolate Chunk Oatmeal Cookie Mix: 6.5/10
Everything about this sounds like it is going to be spectacular in every way! These cookies were a little on the disappointing side for me. The pumpkin spice was just oddly spicy and spicy is not what I’m looking for in a cookie. I liked the texture of the oatmeal, and of course the chocolate chunks were delicious, but the spiciness made me not want another cookie after I finished my first. Usually Trader Joe’s cookie mixes are amazing like the corn cookies and I am very excited for the peppermint chocolate chunk cookies hopefully coming back very soon! Each baking mix is $3.99.
Have you tried this yet? What did you think? (I am not affiliated with Trader Joe’s)
Not my favorite!
Was not a fan.
These aren’t good. I threw them in the trash 😕
Totally agree! Oddly spicy
I bought two of the else last year and HATED them. Idk the flavor is way off to me
Tried these once and they were suuuuper dry
corn cookies?!?
yes I tried these last year and wasn’t a fan, they have a horrible aftertaste!
Agreed – they’re not bad but the cookies were weirdly spicy!
Wait really???? These are easily a 10/10 in my book! I LOVE these cookies!!!! I was surprised by this review!
Ugh, hard disagree. 9/10
Omg nooo!! I must’ve gotten a good batch. These were my all time fav cookies 😍
I add vanilla – game changer
I lovveeee these cookies! They are my fav 😍
these are literally my favorite thing at trader joes
I liked them! But I find it strange it’s one egg for the entire jar. I always make a half batch (or less) so I probably had the wrong amount of egg in mine since I had to mix then pour in half
These were gross 🤢
Agreed-kind of. I actually think if they were just pumpkin chocolate chip cookies they would be good. Adding the oatmeal makes them taste like there is way too much going on.
They grew on me but definitely had a ginger taste to them that threw me off.
I added the salted caramel chips to this & it was soo good!
i absolutely LOVED these. love the airy and light texture so much and love the chocolate chunks
I added salted caramel chips to this and it made it a 7/10 😂 agree it’s a strong taste! Needs to be more sweet
I agree! Too much ginger in a lot of the seasonal products this year!!!
I agree with you – there was a certain sharpness to the cookie that I did not appreciate!